What is the Difference between Silver and White Fillings?

Tooth decay is a common and often unintended issue that affects people of all ages. Your oral health is closely linked to your lifestyle, diet, and hygiene habits. Poor dental care and frequent consumption of sugary or processed foods can significantly increase your risk of cavities. When decay occurs, it’s essential to treat it promptly—and that often means choosing the right type of dental filling. Among the most common options are silver (amalgam) fillings and white (composite) fillings. Understanding the key differences between them can help you make an informed decision about your dental treatment.

When Are Dental Fillings Needed?

Dental fillings are typically required when tooth decay leads to the formation of a cavity. Cavities develop when bacteria feed on food particles stuck in the grooves of your teeth, producing acids that slowly break down the enamel. Over time, this decay damages the tooth’s structure, creating holes that can trap more food, become difficult to clean, and even cause discomfort while eating.

If left untreated, cavities can worsen, leading to pain, sensitivity, or even infection. To restore the tooth and prevent further damage, your dentist will remove the decayed portion and fill the area with a suitable material. Traditionally, silver (amalgam) fillings have been used for their durability. However, modern composite (white) fillings are becoming increasingly popular due to their natural appearance and cosmetic appeal.

‍

Understanding the Difference Between Silver Fillings and White Fillings

Wondering how silver and white fillings compare? While both serve the same purpose—restoring decayed teeth—there are several key differences between them that can influence your choice. Below are some important points to help you understand how silver (amalgam) fillings and white (composite) fillings differ in terms of appearance, durability, cost, and overall benefits.

‍

Amalgam Fillings

Amalgam fillings are one of the most traditional and widely used materials for treating dental cavities. Commonly known as “silver fillings,” the name refers to their colour rather than their composition. In reality, amalgam consists of about 50% elemental mercury, combined with a blend of powdered metals such as silver, tin, and copper—and occasionally small amounts of gold.

The mercury in the mixture binds the metals together, creating a durable and stable material that has been trusted in dentistry for decades. Despite their metallic appearance, amalgam fillings are valued for their strength, especially in back teeth where chewing pressure is greatest.

Advantages of Amalgam Fillings

• Highly Durable and Long-Lasting: Amalgam fillings are known for their strength and resilience. They typically last between 10 to 15 years—or even longer—with minimal risk of cracking or falling out. The material conforms well to the shape of the cavity and hardens securely in place.
• Ideal for Extensive Decay: Amalgam is particularly effective for treating large cavities or multiple decayed teeth. It’s a practical and affordable option for individuals at high risk of developing tooth decay.
• Effective in Moist Conditions: Unlike composite (white) fillings, amalgam does not require a completely dry environment to set properly. This makes it especially useful in areas of the mouth where moisture control is challenging.
• Cost-Effective: Amalgam fillings are generally more affordable than composite fillings, making them a budget-friendly choice for many patients.
• Best for Back Teeth: Because molars and premolars endure greater pressure from chewing, the strength of amalgam makes it a reliable choice for restoring these teeth.

Potential Risks and Disadvantages of Amalgam Fillings

• Unattractive Appearance: The silver colour of amalgam is clearly visible when you speak or laugh, which can be a cosmetic concern, particularly for fillings placed in visible areas.
• Mercury Exposure: Amalgam contains elemental mercury, which can release low levels of mercury vapour over time. While generally considered safe by dental associations, some individuals may be concerned about potential toxic effects if inhaled in significant quantities.
• Not Recommended During Pregnancy: Although research is inconclusive, some health professionals advise against the use of amalgam in pregnant women due to concerns about possible neurotoxic effects on the developing fetus.
• Risk of Mercury Sensitivity: In rare cases, individuals may have an allergic reaction to mercury, which can result in oral lesions or other hypersensitivity symptoms.

‍

White Fillings

White fillings, also known as composite fillings, are made from a tooth-coloured resin designed to blend seamlessly with your natural teeth. This material is a combination of plastic (composite resin) and finely ground glass particles, offering both strength and aesthetics.

The procedure begins with the removal of tooth decay, followed by a process called etching, which involves roughening the surface of the tooth and applying a special gel to enhance bonding. The composite material is then carefully applied in layers and shaped to match the natural contours of your tooth. A curing light—either UV or laser—is used to harden each layer and ensure a strong bond. Finally, the filling is polished and trimmed for a smooth finish that looks and feels like a natural tooth.

White fillings are an excellent option for patients who want a discreet, aesthetically pleasing solution to cavities, especially for front or visible teeth.

Advantages of White Fillings

• Aesthetic Appeal: One of the biggest advantages of white fillings is their natural appearance. They can be closely matched to the shade of your teeth, making them virtually invisible—ideal for front teeth or any visible areas of your smile.
• Tooth Preservation: Composite fillings require less drilling than amalgam, allowing more of your natural tooth structure to remain intact. This conservative approach helps maintain the strength and integrity of the tooth.
• Tooth Reinforcement: White fillings bond directly to the tooth using UV or laser light, which not only helps secure the filling but also adds structural support, reducing the risk of future breakage.
• Durable Performance: When properly placed and cared for, composite fillings can last 4–5 years or more, offering a reliable solution for small to moderate cavities.

Potential Risks and Disadvantages of White Fillings

• Moisture Sensitivity During Placement: Composite fillings require a dry environment during the bonding process. If moisture interferes, the bond may weaken, increasing the risk of the filling coming loose over time.
• Higher Cost: Due to the materials used and the precision required for placement, white fillings tend to be more expensive than traditional amalgam fillings.
• Less Suitable for Large Cavities or Back Teeth: Composite fillings may not be as durable as amalgam when used on molars or in areas with extensive decay, as they can wear down more quickly under heavy chewing pressure.

‍